When shopping for cubic zirconia (CZ) jewelry, you want a piece that sparkles brilliantly and lasts. But with so many options available, how can you tell if cubic zirconia jewelry is high quality? This guide walks you through the key indicators—from grading systems and cut quality to durability and appearance—so you can make an informed purchase.
Understanding the Grading System for Cubic Zirconia
One of the first things you’ll encounter when trying to determine if cubic zirconia jewelry is high quality is the A-grade rating system.
The A to AAAAA Scale
The industry uses a grading scale from A (lowest) to AAAAA or 5A (highest) for machine-cut cubic zirconia stones. Here’s what the grades generally mean:
| Grade | Quality Level |
|---|---|
| A / 1A | Lowest quality; mass-produced with visible flaws |
| AAA | Standard quality found in most commercial jewelry |
| AAAAA / 5A | Highest machine-cut grade; superior brilliance and clarity |
5A cubic zirconia is considered the best among machine-cut stones, with a hardness of 8.5 on the Mohs scale and exceptional optical properties. Some premium retailers even offer a 6A grade, which they claim is perfectly structured, free of inclusions, and totally transparent with superior fire.
A Word of Caution About Grades
It’s important to note that these grading systems lack standardization across the industry. Since cubic zirconia is man-made and mass-produced, quality can be fairly consistent regardless of the claimed grade. The grading system is often used as a marketing tool, so don’t automatically assume that a higher grade guarantees better quality.
Hand-Cut vs. Machine-Cut: A Critical Difference
One of the most significant factors in determining if cubic zirconia jewelry is high quality is how the stone was cut.
Machine-Cut CZ
Machine-cut stones are mass-produced, which sacrifices quality and precision. While they can still be beautiful, they lack the meticulous attention to detail found in hand-cut stones.
Hand-Cut CZ
Hand-cut cubic zirconia stones are individually crafted by highly trained professionals with great precision. When cut properly, a hand-cut CZ can achieve the same luminosity as fine diamonds. This is why, when shopping for hand-cut CZ, it’s essential to purchase from a reputable jeweler who guarantees the quality of their stones.
Key Quality Indicators to Look For
Beyond the grade and cut method, here are the specific characteristics to examine when assessing if cubic zirconia jewelry is high quality:
1. Clarity
High-quality cubic zirconia should be virtually flawless. Unlike natural diamonds, which almost always have some internal imperfections (inclusions), CZ is manufactured to be optically clean. If you can see visible bubbles, cloudiness, or inclusions with the naked eye or a simple jeweler’s loupe, the quality is low.
2. Color
Premium cubic zirconia is completely colorless, comparable to a “D” grade on the diamond color scale—the highest possible rating. In contrast, most natural diamonds have a slight yellow or brown tint. If your CZ has a noticeable gray or yellow tinge, it’s not top quality.
3. Cut Quality
The cut determines how light interacts with the stone. A high-quality CZ will have:
-
Symmetrical, well-proportioned facets
-
No abrasions or tiny scratches along the facet junctions
-
Excellent light return (brilliance) and fire
4. Brilliance vs. Fire
-
Brilliance is the reflection of white light.
-
Fire is the dispersion of colored light (rainbow flashes).
Cubic zirconia has a higher dispersive power than diamond (0.060 vs. 0.044), meaning it displays more fire—more colorful sparkle. While this is a characteristic of the material, a high-quality CZ will have this fire evenly distributed and well-balanced, not appearing “overly flashy” or distorted.
5. Setting Quality
The metal setting matters too. To ensure if cubic zirconia jewelry is high quality, examine the:
-
Metal type: Sterling silver and stainless steel are ideal complements to CZ. Avoid cheap plated metals (brass, silver, or copper plated with gold) as the plating wears off quickly.
-
Craftsmanship: Look for smooth prongs, secure settings, and overall attention to detail.
Durability Considerations
Cubic zirconia scores 8 to 8.5 on the Mohs hardness scale, making it reasonably durable but significantly softer than diamond (which scores 10). This means:
-
With daily wear, a CZ typically maintains its appearance for about two years before it may become cloudy, scratched, or lose its brilliance.
-
CZ absorbs oils from the skin, which can dull its sparkle over time.
A high-quality CZ won’t prevent this—it’s a characteristic of the material. This is why CZ is often recommended for fashion jewelry, temporary rings, or as a “travel ring” substitute for a diamond.
Quick Checklist: How to Tell If Cubic Zirconia Jewelry Is High Quality
| Quality Factor | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Clarity | No visible bubbles, inclusions, or cloudiness |
| Color | Completely colorless (no yellow or gray tinge) |
| Cut | Symmetrical facets, no scratches, excellent light return |
| Fire | Balanced rainbow sparkle, not overly flashy or distorted |
| Setting | Quality metal (sterling silver or stainless steel), secure prongs |
| Reputation | Buy from a jeweler who guarantees their stone quality |





